A report on proposals for a new Tobermory 2-18 Campus will go before the Community Services Committee on 10 December. It brings together consultation feedback from pupils, families, staff and the wider community, as well as independent findings from His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Education in Scotland (HMIE) and the Council’s response. Councillors will consider all of this information before deciding whether the proposal should move to the next stage.
The report considers plans to replace the existing, ageing Tobermory Campus, Argyll and Bute’s only school currently rated “C – poor” for suitability, with a modern campus at Tobermory South. The proposal would increase usable internal space by around a third, with improved specialist and vocational learning facilities, significantly increased sports provision, dedicated support for pupils with additional needs, and better indoor and outdoor learning environments.
Feedback from pupils, parents, carers, staff and communities, alongside HMIE’s independent report, has helped inform the next steps. HM Inspectors of Education (HMIE) recognised the clear educational rationale for replacing the campus and its potential benefits for learning, wellbeing and achievement.
The Council has responded individually to HMIE conclusions with which it disagrees, explaining that the consultation was open to everyone, including those outside the campus catchment; a split-site option had been considered and ruled out through formal Council decisions in December 2024; and pupils from all affected schools had age-appropriate opportunities to contribute, with additional support where needed. In response to HMIE’s request for more detail, the Council explains that detailed design can be finalised only after the necessary statutory and governance stages.
Having considered the full report, which includes consultation responses, pupils’ views and the HMIE’s report, the Committee will determine whether to proceed with relocation to Tobermory South.
Councillor Kieron Green, Policy Lead for Education, said:
“We recognise the strength of feeling around this project and thank everyone who shared their views, particularly our children and young people. The report from HMIE reflects this range of perspectives, and we have carefully considered every point raised giving evidence and reasoning. This proposal offers a significant opportunity to give children and young people a modern, accessible campus with more space and improved facilities for learning, sport and additional support.”
For more information about Tobermory Campus, visit the council website https://www.argyll-bute.gov.uk/education-and-learning/schools/tobermory-campus-project