Agenda and minutes

Argyll and Bute Community Planning Partnership - Management Committee - Wednesday, 16 September 2009 10:00 am

Venue: Oban Fire Station, Oban

Items
No. Item

1.

WELCOME

Minutes:

ARGYLL AND BUTE COMMUNITY PLANNING PARTNERSHIP

 

MINUTES of MEETING of COMMUNITY PLANNING MANAGEMENT

COMMITTEE

held in Community Fire Station, Oban on

Wednesday 16 September 2009

 

Present:

         Sally Loudon                                       Argyll and Bute Council

         Raymond Park (Chair)                        Strathclyde Police

         Jane Fowler                                        Argyll and Bute Council

         Eileen Wilson                                      Argyll and Bute Council

         Brian Barker                                        Argyll and Bute Council

         Douglas Cowan                                  Highlands and Islands Enterprise

         Derek Leslie                                        NHS Highland

         David Penman                                    Strathclyde Fire and Rescue

         Geoff Calvert                                       Strathclyde Fire and Rescue

         Gemma Gibb                                      Strathclyde Fire and Rescue

         Peter Russell                                      Scottish Government

         Andrew Campbell                               Scottish Natural Heritage

         Frances Webster                                Skills Development Scotland

         Isobel Millar                                         Skills Development Scotland

         Alan Murray                                         Strathclyde Partnership for Transport

         David Price                                         Association of Argyll and Bute Community Councils

         Glenn Heritage                                    Argyll and Bute Volunteer Centre

         John Davidson                                    Islay and Jura CVS

 

In attendance:

         Joyce Cameron (Minutes)                  Argyll and Bute Council

                                 

Apologies:

         Malcolm MacFadyen                           Argyll and Bute Council

         David Dowie                                        Scottish Government

         David Duthie                                       Hitrans

         Keith Philip                                          Strathclyde Police

         Scott Armstrong                                  Visit Scotland

         Roanna Taylor                                    Argyll and Bute Young Scot/Dialogue Youth

        

 

 

ITEM

DETAIL

ACTION

 

1.

 

WELCOME

 

Raymond Park welcomed everyone to the meeting and noted apologies.

 

 

 

 

 

2.

 

MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 22 JULY 2009

 

Minutes of previous meeting dated 22 July 2009 were agreed.

 

 

 

 

3.

 

MATTERS ARISING

 

Ag Item 6

Thematic Groups – Item is covered within this agenda.

 

Ag Item 7

Community Planning Conference – Eileen Wilson advised that this is still work in progress.

 

Ag Item 10(b)

Action point should read via ABVC

 

3a) THIRD SECTOR INTERFACE

 

Brian Barker advised that there have been four responses to the third sector interface and ODS Consulting had been appointed to undertake the work in relation to this. The consultants have been briefed and provided with initial contacts. The report will be completed by the end of October.

 

3(b)(i) THIRD SECTOR POSITION STATEMENT AND DIAGRAM LINKS

 

Glenn Heritage briefed the Management Committee on the content of the position statement from the Third Sector Partnership.

Brian Barker advised that whilst good progress is being made there still needs to be a dialogue between CPP and Third Sector on development of the interface.

 

The paper implies that the Third Sector Partnership will become the interface. This is not necessarily the case, the interface will be developed through dialogue based on the outputs from the research. The dialogue will include the Third Sector partners and others providing support to the Third Sector – including the island CVSs.

 

The draft terms of reference and structure for the Third Sector Partnership are available from Glenn Heritage.

 

3(b)(ii) – ISLAY AND JURA CVS RESPONSE

 

John Davidson advised that there has been particular success with dialogue between IJCVS and Bute Community Links. Legal advice is currently being sought about the scope and remit of the island CVSs in advance of plans to merge the two organisations.

 

A separate update from Bute Community Links was also circulated.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

4.

 

 

 

 

 

DRAFT COMMUNITY PLAN

 

Eileen Wilson advised that the Draft Community Plan had been e-mailed to all partners on Friday 11 September.

 

Key points from the discussion were:

·         To review wording around some of the economy priorities

·         To review wording on DriveSafe to reflect new priorities for the partnership

·         That the plan needs to be more dynamic and respond to future changes/challenges – though it was noted that it is not set in tablets of stone.

·         Whilst budgets are not yet detailed in the plan, this work should be undertaken.

 

The Community Plan priorities and content were agreed in principle

 

David Penman to present more detail on DriveSafe and road traffic collision statistics to the next meeting.

 

Action Points

 

Any feedback/comments on the Community Plan to be with Eileen Wilson by the end of September.

 

Strathclyde Fire and rescue to provide an update at the next Management Committee meeting.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

All Partners

 

 

 

David Penman

 

5.                              

 

DRAFT SOA ANNUAL REPORT

 

The draft report was considered and agreed.

 

Discussion on the annual report touched on the traffic lights highlighting performance levels and the fact that it was the responsibility of all partners to support action to address “red” traffic lights – not the lead partner alone.

 

All partners welcomed the fact that discussion was now focusing on performance and how to address weak areas. It was noted that the development of scorecards for Community Planning would make performance management easier and Sally Loudon reported that she has asked the Council’s internal audit team to verify the data in performance scorecards . Derek Leslie highlighted the progress in the last year towards evidence based accreditation of performance.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

6.

 

RISK REGISTER UPDATE

The paper was agreed with the following changes;

 

Risk No.6

Wording revised to “Potential increase in drugs misuse due to economic climate.”

 

Risk No. 19

Changes are to be made to the wording. Derek Leslie to provide details to Brian.

 

Risk No.10

Possibly no longer a risk in current form. Revise wording to reflect risks relating to infrastructure to support renewables.

 

Action Point

Column to be added detailing mitigating actions

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Derek Leslie

 

 

 

Brian Barker

 

 

Brian Barker

 

 

7.

 

 

SKILLS DEVELOPMENT SCOTLAND

 

Isobel Millar gave a presentation on Skills Development Scotland.

 

Questions and discussion highlighted important links between the work of Skills Development Scotland and other partners – for example existing links with Employability and possible links with the Strathclyde Fire and Rescue Young Firefighters scheme. Isobel indicated that it would be possible to provide some data at area level.

 

 

 

 

 

 

8.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

HIE COMMUNITY ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT

 

This paper was noted.

 

Action Point

Data for fragile areas will be extracted and circulated.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Douglas Cowan

 

 

9.        

 

FAIRER SCOTLAND FUND

 

Brian Barker advised that the funding is ring fenced this year but not next.

 

Given the uncertain position of public sector finances and the impending decision on the Council’s review of Community Learning & Regeneration (some of which is funded by FSF), the Management Committee agreed to adopt a cautious approach and confirm that, FSF should not be allocated until the position is clearer. The process of reviewing whether currently funded activity  ...  view the full minutes text for item 1.

2.

MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 22 JULY 2009 pdf icon PDF 71 KB

A

Minutes:

Minutes of previous meeting dated 22 July 2009 were agreed.

3.

MATTERS ARISING

Minutes:

Ag Item 6

Thematic Groups – Item is covered within this agenda.

 

Ag Item 7

Community Planning Conference – Eileen Wilson advised that this is still work in progress.

 

Ag Item 10(b)

Action point should read via ABVC

3a

Third Sector Interface pdf icon PDF 78 KB

Minutes:

Brian Barker advised that there have been four responses to the third sector interface and ODS Consulting had been appointed to undertake the work in relation to this.  The consultants have been briefed and provided with initial contacts.  The report will be completed by the end of October.

3b

Third Sector Position Statement and Diagram Links pdf icon PDF 82 KB

Minutes:

Glenn Heritage briefed the Management Committee on the content of the position statement from the Third Sector Partnership.

Brian Barker advised that whilst good progress is being made there still needs to be a dialogue between CPP and Third Sector on development of the interface.

 

The paper implies that the Third Sector Partnership will become the interface.  This is not necessarily the case, the interface will be developed through dialogue based on the outputs from the research.  The dialogue will include the Third Sector partners and others providing support to the Third Sector – including the island CVSs.

 

The draft terms of reference and structure for the Third Sector Partnership are available from Glenn Heritage.

3c

Islay and Jura CVS Response pdf icon PDF 97 KB

Minutes:

John Davidson advised that there has been particular success with dialogue between IJCVS and Bute Community Links.  Legal advise is currently being sought about the scope and remit of the island CVSs in advance of plans to merge the two organisations.

 

A separate update from Bute Community Links was also circulated.

4.

DRAFT COMMUNITY PLAN

Minutes:

Eileen Wilson advised that the Draft Community Plan had been e-mailed to all partners on Friday 11 September.

 

Key points from the discussion were:

  • To review wording around some of the economy priorities
  • To review wording on DriveSafe to reflect new priorities for the partnership.
  • That the plan needs to be more dynamic and respond to future changes/challenges – though it was noted that it is not set in tablets of stone.
  • Whilst budgets are not yet detailed in the plan, this work should be undertaken.

 

The Community Plan priorities and content were agreed in principle.

 

David Penman to present more detail on DriveSafe and road traffic collision statistics to the next meeting.

 

Action Points

 

Any feedback/comments on the Community Plan to be with Eileen Wilson by the end of September – All Partners

 

Strathclyde Fire and rescue to provide an update at the next Management Committee meeting – David Penman

5.

DRAFT SOA ANNUAL REPORT pdf icon PDF 64 KB

a

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The draft report was considered and agreed.

 

Discussion on the annual report touched on the traffic lights highlighting performance levels and the fact that it was the responsibility of all partners to support action to address “red” traffic lights – not the lead partner alone.

 

All partners welcomed the fact that discussion was now focusing on performance and how to address weak areas.  It was noted that the development of scorecards for Community Planning would make performance management easier and Sally Loudon reported that she has asked the Council’s internal audit team to verify the data in performance scorecards.  Derek Leslie highlighted the progress in the last year towards evidence based accreditation of performance.

6.

RISK REGISTER UPDATE pdf icon PDF 63 KB

a

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The paper was agreed with the following changes;

 

Risk No.6

Wording revised to “Potential increase in drugs misuse due to economic climate.”

 

Risk No.19

Changes are to be made to the wording.  Derek Leslie to provide details to Brian.

 

Risk No.10

Possibly no longer a risk in current form.  Revise wording to reflect risks relating to infrastructure to support renewables.

 

Action Point

Column to be added detailing mitigating actions – Brian Barker

7.

SKILLS DEVELOPMENT SCOTLAND pdf icon PDF 759 KB

a

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Isobel Millar gave a presentation on Skills Development Scotland.

 

Questions and discussion highlighted important links between the work of Skills Development Scotland and other partners – for example existing links with Employability and possible links with the Strathclyde Fire and Rescue Young Firefighters scheme.  Isobel indicated that it would be possible to provide some data at area level.

8.

HIE COMMUNITY ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT pdf icon PDF 52 KB

a

Minutes:

This paper was noted.

 

Action Point

Data for fragile areas will be extracted and circulated – Douglas Cowan

9.

FAIRER SCOTLAND FUND pdf icon PDF 234 KB

a

Minutes:

Brian Barker advised that the funding is ring fenced this year but not next.

 

Given the uncertain position of public sector finances and the impending decision on the Council’s review of Community Learning & Regeneration (some of which is funded by FSF), the Management Committee agreed to adopt a cautious approach and confirm that, FSF should not be allocated until the position is clearer.  The process of reviewing whether currently funded activity continues to receive funding should continue by the FAB Assessment panel.

 

Action Point

Update at future Management Committee Meeting – Brian Barker

10.

HIE ECONOMIC UPDATE pdf icon PDF 261 KB

a

Minutes:

This report was welcomed and should continue to come to future meetings.  Douglas highlighted that Dunoon and Rothesay are currently experiencing significant challenges in unemployment levels and are the priority areas for targeted intervention.  Campbeltown is in a similar position regarding unemployment levels, but the current partner activity supporting major investment provides a positive framework for tackling the issue.

 

Action Point

Douglas was asked to provide more detail on the Scottish Futures Trust – Douglas Cowan

11.

CITIZEN'S PANEL pdf icon PDF 576 KB

a

Minutes:

This paper was noted.

 

Action Point

After each Citizen Panel survey Partners were asked to feedback detail on how they use the Citizens Panel information to show that the information is being used in consideration of changes to plans and service delivery.  This would be collated and fed back to survey participants – All Partners

 

A calendar will be developed to show the timing and content of future surveys – Eileen Wilson

12.

FUNDING UPDATE

12a

European Funding pdf icon PDF 211 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

A calendar will be developed to show times and content of future surveys.

 

It was advised that there is funding available for CPP.  A short list of projects has been put forward indicating likely priority areas.

12b

Funding Hub Minute of 22 July 2009 pdf icon PDF 71 KB

Minutes:

This paper was noted.

13.

THEMATIC COMMUNITY PLANNING GROUP FEEDBACK - a), b) and c) pdf icon PDF 220 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

All the Thematic groups have had meetings with some issues being raised.  The groups are at a very early stage and are moving forward positively.

 

A question of “where does transport fit in” prompted discussion and recognition that there will be topics that cross one or more themes.

 

It was advised that scorecards will be presented to CPP Management Committee in the future with a brief report on successes and planned actions.

14.

LOCAL AREA COMMUNITY PLANNING GROUPS

Minutes:

Eileen Wilson advised that more preparation work needs to be done based on initial experience with the Thematic Groups.  The first round of meetings is now scheduled for November.

15.

2010 CPP MEETING SCHEDULE pdf icon PDF 48 KB

A

Minutes:

This paper was noted.

16.

AOCB

Minutes:

David Price invited the group to the AGM of ACVS/VC which is being held in the Council Chambers at 12 noon on Tuesday 13 October 2009.

 

Derek Leslie highlighted that the Scottish Ambulance Service has an important role in public service delivery and so should have a role in Community Planning because of the potential to deliver more in partnership.

 

ACTION POINT

 

Raymond Park to invite the Scottish Ambulance Service to the Management Committee on 11 November 2009.

 

DATE OF NEXT MEETING: 11 November at HIE Offices, Lochgilphead